Why I am unhappy Carnival Cruise Line is retiring its smallest ship

Carnival Cruise Line’s oldest and smallest ship, the two,052-passenger Carnival Ecstasy, is not probably the most awe-inspiring cruise vessel afloat. Not by an extended shot.

Its high deck lacks the kind of splashy, family-fun sights discovered on newer Carnival ships, reminiscent of sprawling water parks, ropes programs, high-in-the-sky pedal rides and — on Carnival’s new flagship Mardi Gras — even a curler coaster. Few of its cabins provide balconies, which might make them really feel claustrophobic.

At 31 years of age, it additionally simply feels … worn out. Time has taken its toll.

Join our every day publication

Nevertheless, regardless of all of that, I discover myself struck with unhappiness this week that Carnival Ecstasy is on its remaining voyage for the road.

For extra cruise information, guides and ideas, join TPG’s cruise publication

For starters, it is a reminder that I, too, am getting previous. I am sufficiently old to recollect when Carnival Ecstasy was one of many latest and most superior cruise ships on the planet. I have been writing about cruising for therefore lengthy that I can recall writing about — and crusing on — Carnival Ecstasy when it was one of many cruise world’s vivid younger issues.

That is not the primary purpose, nevertheless, that I really feel a tinge of melancholy this week upon occupied with the retirement of a ship that’s bumping up in opposition to the tip of its helpful life. Cruise ships are constructed to final about 30 years.

What the retirement of Carnival Ecstasy from the Carnival fleet represents to me is the newest nail within the coffin of what I prefer to name the period of the intimate floating megaresort — emphasis on intimate.


Carnival Ecstasy is without doubt one of the final remaining vessels on the huge mainstream traces reminiscent of Carnival, Royal Caribbean and Norwegian Cruise Line that dates again to a time when megaships had been huge however not that huge.

Designed to hold round 2,000 vacationers as in comparison with the 6,000-plus that the largest cruise ships carry right this moment, they had been vessels of a dimension that provided quite a lot of facilities (therefore, the megaship moniker) however nonetheless felt cozy and never too crowded.

Associated: The last word information to Carnival Cruise Line

On these ships, you had been vacationing with a big variety of different individuals, for certain, however not almost as many as you may discover on modern-day vessels.

There was a stage of intimacy within the huge ships of Carnival Ecstasy’s heyday that — to my remorse — is quick disappearing.

When megaships weren’t fairly so mega

Carnival Ecstasy was, notably, considered one of eight comparable Carnival vessels unveiled between 1990 and 1998 that elevated the road into the massive leagues of the North American tourism enterprise.

On the time Carnival Ecstasy debuted, Carnival had only a handful of ships — all considerably smaller and with fewer facilities. The arrival of the vessel and its seven sisters in fast succession within the Nineteen Nineties helped drive the expansion of the cruise trade in North America and catapulted the road into a significant tourism firm.

These had been ships that, in a extra complete approach than Carnival’s earlier vessels, provided up numerous decktop pool and lounge areas, in addition to sprawling inside public areas filled with bars, showrooms, eating places and retailers.

Associated: The 8 courses of Carnival ships, defined

Together with a brand new sequence of so-called Sovereign-class ships at rival Royal Caribbean that had been roughly the identical dimension, they had been the megaships of their day.

Nevertheless, as famous above, they had been a fraction of the dimensions of right this moment’s megaships. At 70,367 tons, Carnival Ecstasy was one of many largest cruise ships on the planet when it debuted in 1991. It is now lower than half the dimensions of the world’s largest cruise ships, together with Mardi Gras. The brand new Carnival flagship measures 181,808 tons and might carry 5,282 passengers at double occupancy (6,465 with each pulldown bunk and pullout couch crammed).

Carnival Ecstasy at sea. CARNIVAL CRUISE LINE

Over time, cruise ships have simply gotten greater and larger. That is partly as a result of greater ships are extra economical for traces to function. There are economies of scale that make them a greater enterprise proposition. Nevertheless, greater than that, it is as a result of greater ships are what a good portion of the cruising public desires.

As any government at Carnival, Royal Caribbean or Norwegian will let you know, the mantra of would-be cruisers for years has been “give me extra onboard choices” — extra decktop amusements, extra bars, extra eating places, extra showrooms. To ship on this, the corporate needed to go greater with the ships. For a lot of megaship-loving cruisers, greater is best.

I’ll stipulate the truth that, in relation to megaships, the newer, greater vessels have much more to supply. For the final word megaship expertise, it is onerous to beat a vessel reminiscent of Royal Caribbean’s 236,857-ton Surprise of the Seas — the world’s largest cruise ship. This can be a ship so huge that it has a number of primary pool areas, a kiddie splash zone, browsing simulators, a miniature golf course, a basketball court docket and even a zipper line. And that’s simply on its high deck. Contained in the vessel, you’ll discover extra lounges, bars, eating places and retailers than you may think about, plus an enormous on line casino, spas, theaters and even an ice-skating rink.

Nevertheless, I nonetheless have a particular fondness for the smaller megaships of previous, reminiscent of Carnival Ecstasy — and it isn’t simply because I miss the intimacy that lots of the megaships of the Nineteen Nineties (and even the 2000s) provided.

These smaller megaships are also extra versatile, in a position to sail out of smaller ports reminiscent of Cellular, Alabama (the house of Carnival Ecstasy till this week), that may not be capable to help a much bigger vessel. In addition they can entry smaller vacation spot ports reminiscent of Havana, Cuba, that are not reachable by greater ships. Ought to Havana ever reopen to North American-based cruise ships once more, solely smaller ships reminiscent of Carnival Ecstasy would be capable to pull proper into its harbor.

The top of the ‘small’ megaship period

Till only a few years in the past, all of us might “have our cake and eat it, too” when it got here to huge and small megaships. There have been ever extra really large megaships rolling out, however lots of the smaller megaships that dated to the late Eighties and Nineteen Nineties nonetheless had been round.

That every one has modified fairly out of the blue in simply the previous three years, because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

An industrywide shutdown lasting greater than a yr and plunging bookings prompted lots of the largest cruise traces together with Carnival, Royal Caribbean, Holland America and Princess to retire lots of their oldest ships, which had been additionally their smallest ships.

Carnival, notably, entered the COVID-19 downturn with all eight of its small Fantasy class ships nonetheless crusing. In early 2020, the eight vessels accounted for a couple of third of all the Carnival fleet. Inside months, although, Carnival had introduced the fast retirement of 4 of the eight vessels, and earlier this yr it retired the fifth vessel within the sequence.

After this week’s crusing of Carnival Ecstasy ends Saturday, it should turn into the sixth of the unique eight Fantasy-class ships to depart the Carnival fleet.

As of subsequent week, there will probably be simply two of those small Carnival ships left, the two,130-passenger Carnival Elation and the two,124-passenger Carnival Paradise.

Carnival’s sister model Holland America eliminated 4 of its oldest, smallest ships through the COVID-19 downturn, amounting to 29% of its fleet. Princess Cruises eliminated 5 of its older, smaller ships from its fleet prior to now three years.

The COVID-19 disaster additionally noticed the retirement of Royal Caribbean’s two smallest ships, Empress of the Seas and Majesty of the Seas.

Briefly, the panorama of comparatively small, intimate ships among the many huge mainstream traces has modified drastically over the previous few years. And, to me, that is one thing to lament, even when it is a pure a part of the evolution of the cruise enterprise.

Planning a cruise? Begin with these tales:

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button