My business-class seat was damaged. Can I get a refund?

On a current flight from Zurich to Philadelphia, American Airways business-class passenger Jyotish Bhalla found her seat was damaged.

A business-class seat that was imagined to lie flat froze in a clumsy, upright place. Bhalla, who had hoped to relaxation on the nine-hour flight, spent most of it unpleasantly caught in a single place.

Bhalla says she paid $4,800 to fly in that damaged business-class seat and needs a refund. However American Airways rejected that request and as a substitute awarded her simply 5,000 miles for the mishap.

That “insulting” response to her criticism solely served to make this seat fiasco worse, Bhalla says.

Now she’s hoping that TPG can persuade American Airways to supply a refund for her disappointing flight.

Reserving and rebooking a Viking cruise

As quickly because the cruise trade started its revival final 12 months, Bhalla began planning of her personal.

“I booked a Viking river cruise scheduled for July 2021,” she instructed me. “I paid for the whole journey, together with airfare, however then, quickly after, the cruise was canceled.”

Crestfallen, however not solely shocked by the cancellation, Bhalla selected to rebook the identical Rhine river cruise itinerary a number of months later. She hoped by that point the pandemic would now not be affecting the cruise trade.

Sadly, the coronavirus wasn’t solely completed wreaking havoc all over the world, and Bhalla did not cruise on the backup voyage both. She was starting to surprise if she’d ever discover herself stress-free aboard Viking’s Egdir because it made its means by the Rhine Valley.

Join our every day e-newsletter

Undeterred, she rebooked the identical cruise another time. Lastly, it seemed just like the ship was going to sail.

However then, a well being disaster threatened Bhalla’s cruising plans.

An sudden surgical procedure and a crucial business-class improve


Because the cruise date loomed, Bhalla had an sudden medical disaster that compelled her to have surgical procedure on her foot. After the process, she determined to proceed along with her plans to take the long-awaited Viking cruise. On the recommendation of her doctor, she paid to improve to enterprise class to maintain her leg elevated all through the lengthy flight.

Making use of some leftover credit from her beforehand canceled cruise, Viking charged Bhalla round an extra $3,000 to improve her ticket to enterprise class.

On the finish of July, after almost two years of ready for an opportunity to securely cruise once more, Bhalla boarded an American Airways flight headed to Europe.

As she reclined her comfortable business-class seat into its absolutely flat place, she was happy that she’d chosen to undergo with the journey. She would quickly be taking within the view of the Rhine River from her balcony on Viking Egdir. It was precisely what she wanted.

Sitting in a damaged business-class seat the entire means residence

For the subsequent week, Bhalla had an exquisite time. The Viking river cruise was all the things she hoped it will be. Her journey had been an enormous success.

That’s, till she boarded the flight residence from Zurich. After which issues took a decidedly terrible flip.

Bhalla had very a lot loved all of the options of her business-class seat on the best way to Europe. She was anticipating the identical consolation as she settled in for the lengthy flight residence. However to her shock, nothing occurred when she pressed the button to increase the leg relaxation. She pushed it once more, however nonetheless nothing. Then she tried to recline and the headrest moved barely, then froze altogether.

Throughout Bhalla, the opposite business-class passengers have been getting snug, however her seat remained nonfunctional.

“The pinnacle purser got here to me and tried to assist,” Bhalla instructed me. “He reset the system, after which he tried another issues. Nevertheless it was clear my business-class seat was damaged. He apologized and mentioned he had nowhere to maneuver me.”

When Bhalla, a health care provider, defined to the purser why her legs wanted to be elevated in the course of the flight, he got here up with an concept.

A makeshift business-class seat

The purser disappeared into the galley and shortly returned with some provides: pillows, a blanket and a metallic field.

First, the purser compelled the seat right into a 45-degree recline. Subsequent, he arrange the metallic field on the ground in entrance of Bhalla. Then he layered a number of blankets and pillows on prime of the metallic field till it was excessive sufficient for Bhalla to raise her legs.

“Along with being fairly cumbersome,” Bhalla defined, “it was maybe slightly unsafe to climb over the crate to get out into the aisle.”

However given no different choice, this makeshift setup must do. Bhalla spent the remainder of the flight along with her seat caught in that place. She tried as finest as doable to maintain her legs elevated on prime of the metallic field, pillows and blankets. It was a slipshod contraption.

“I undoubtedly didn’t get the business-class seat I paid for,” Bhalla mentioned.

Asking American Airways to refund the flight

Many hours later, when the flight landed, Bhalla was pissed off and drained. Now she had a four-hour drive to get residence and was anxious to get on the street. The useful purser assured her that he would file an incident report and somebody from American Airways could be in contact about compensation.

A number of days after arriving residence, Bhalla acquired a brief e mail from American Airways and a compensation notification.

“American Airways anticipated me to just accept 5,000 miles as compensation,” Bhalla complained. “I paid $4,500 for a round-trip business-class seat, and mine was fully damaged on the best way again. 5 thousand miles as compensation is insulting.”

Bhalla then emailed American Airways straight in regards to the damaged business-class seat she had no selection however to fly in regardless of her medical situation. She made it clear her expectations included a refund for that flight:

I’m a Gold [AAdvantage] member and have lengthy been a buyer of American Airways. On August 2, I flew flight AA 93 from Zürich to Philadelphia in enterprise class, seat 3A.

The seat didn’t operate in any respect. Having had current surgical procedure and regardless of sporting compression hose, I wanted to maintain my leg elevated to forestall swelling, ache, and subsequent issues, for which I now have an appointment with my surgeon.

As well as, it was very important for me to lie flat and get ample sleep as I had a 4 Hour drive from Philadelphia to my residence. Neither of those was doable as there have been no different seats out there. The purser supplied me with a field and pillows so I may attempt to preserve my leg elevated.

This was not the enterprise class expertise I bought.

American Airways: No additional compensation

In response to her follow-up criticism, American Airways reevaluated its preliminary provide and awarded Bhalla a $300 journey credit score.

Nonetheless unhappy and feeling as if American Airways was not valuing a long-term, loyal buyer, Bhalla despatched extra emails. And extra emails.

However American Airways let Bhalla know there could be no additional compensation:

On this case, the bonus miles have been meant as a tangible apology to indicate that we care about you and your expertise. I can see that you simply really feel strongly about this concern; subsequently, I’ve reviewed our prior correspondence.

Regrettably, I do not see any info that will change our decision.

Relaxation assured, we aren’t unmindful of your issues. We take your suggestions severely, because it helps us establish areas we have to enhance. Please know that we’re grateful for the advantage of your perspective.

We respect your AAdvantage® loyalty very a lot, Dr. Bhalla, and hope to have the chance to welcome you on board one other American flight.

Together with her frustration turning to anger at American Airways, the very last thing she may think about was permitting the airline to welcome her aboard one other flight.

Bhalla then determined to ship her criticism to and see if we may assist.

Asking American Airways to rethink this passenger’s plight

Once I reviewed the main points of Bhalla’s expertise within the damaged business-class seat, I actually thought she deserved greater than a $300 future credit score.

Studying by the correspondence between Bhalla and a few of the American Airways brokers, I did not get the sensation that any of the workers absolutely grasped the state of affairs.

At one level, an American Airways consultant recommended that if Bhalla actually hadn’t needed to just accept that damaged business-class seat, she may have simply requested to be moved to a unique flight. Hardly a sensible answer because the plane was 30,000 ft above the bottom when it grew to become clear the seat was nonfunctional.

Sadly, as a client advocate, I do know that not all customer support brokers are as attentive and useful as we’d hope. It appeared that Bhalla had uncovered a couple of of the less-than-caring representatives. Actually, she says that one consultant referred to as her on the telephone after which rudely hung up on her once they did not see eye to eye on the state of affairs.

It was time to escalate this case to our useful American Airways govt and see what her workforce may do for Bhalla. This individual is a media contact that we are able to method straight about circumstances like this slightly than a public-facing customer support consultant.

The excellent news: An appropriate decision from American Airways

I despatched all the main points of Bhalla’s expertise to our govt contact at American Airways. I included a drawing Bhalla created for instance her damaged business-class seat and the contraption that the purser set as much as try to accommodate her have to elevate her legs.

Then we hit a snag.

Cruise traces purchase specifically priced tickets in bulk from the airways. So when a passenger purchases their airfare by way of the cruise line, the airline can not at all times pin down the precise worth of the ticket.

The American Airways govt workforce needed to supply a good decision primarily based on the worth of the ticket, however that worth was unclear.

Moreover, all of us agreed {that a} full refund was not warranted because the airline did transport Bhalla throughout the pond again residence. She additionally acquired the meals and beverage providers related to enterprise class.

After some extra digging by the Viking contract, American Airways agreed to boost the compensation to a $1,000 journey credit score transferable to family and friends, plus 5,000 miles.

And though Bhalla isn’t blissful along with her business-class expertise or the next battle to get justice, she is delighted with the result.

What to do a couple of damaged business-class seat

Here is what you are able to do earlier than, throughout and after takeoff in the event you’re confronted with a damaged seat in enterprise class or some other cabin.

Verify your seat’s features ASAP

Once you board your business-class flight, your first thought may be to take a look at the amenity equipment or order a drink. However you must at all times test your seat for its performance first.

That is when the cabin crew can reassign you in case your seat isn’t working accurately. Keep in mind, most airways fill empty business-class seats with folks on the improve listing earlier than takeoff.

So the longer you wait to test that your seat is working correctly, the upper the chance that there will not be an open seat to change to if wanted.

Ask for an improve or downgrade

If there aren’t any open seats in your cabin, you possibly can ask to be upgraded to the first-class cabin in case your flight has one.

Your subsequent choice is to think about a downgrade if the state of your seat isn’t tolerable or is unsafe (as an illustration, if the seat belt is nonfunctional).

Take into accout in the event you’re flying from Europe or flying on a European airline in both route, below Article 10 of EU261, you possibly can apply for involuntary downgrade compensation when you’ve got no selection however to just accept a transfer to a decrease class of service. The cost relies on the flight size and solely applies to the downgraded portion of the journey.

Downgraded flights between the U.S. and Europe qualify for a 75% refund. You may learn extra in regards to the passenger protections EU261 gives in TPG’s information.

Ask to be moved to a later flight

After all, this solely applies in the event you’re nonetheless on the bottom. But when the issue along with your seat isn’t one thing you possibly can tolerate and a downgrade or improve isn’t an choice, you possibly can ask to be moved to the subsequent out there flight.

Once more, in case you are in Europe, the airline may have an extra “obligation of care” duty for you. EU261 ensures that in case you are compelled off the flight due to your seat concern, the airline ought to present lodge, meals and transportation prices to and from the airport if an in a single day keep is critical.

Tolerate the damaged seat

So long as the issue along with your seat does not pose a security concern, chances are you’ll determine to tolerate the state of affairs. On this case, take pictures and movies of the nonfunctioning seat.

Later, while you file your criticism with the airline, these pictures will assist your grievance. Displaying a customer support agent or govt contact at an organization precisely what you tolerated will typically garner a extra sympathetic response than simply your narrative of the issue.

Request compensation from the airline

There are a couple of steps you need to take with a purpose to request compensation from an airline in the event you suppose you’re due any.

  1. Once you arrive residence, compose a brief, well mannered and affordable request for compensation to the airline.
  2. When scripting this e mail, do not forget that you wish to make the individual receiving your message wish to assist you to.
  3. Chorus from threatening by no means to fly the airline once more or implying that you simply’re getting a lawyer concerned.
  4. Don’t blast e mail a number of executives throughout the firm. Such a criticism typically lands within the digital rubbish can since every individual on that listing can assume another person will reply, and you will get no response in any respect.

File a criticism with the US Division of Transportation

If you happen to have been compelled to take a seat in a damaged seat and the airline ignores your criticism for compensation, your final step is to file a criticism with the Division of Transportation.

The airline should reply to your criticism by way of the DOT inside 60 days. It’d ignore you, however I promise it is not going to ignore the DOT.

Backside line

Nobody desires to fly throughout the Atlantic in a damaged business-class seat. Though it does not occur often, in the event you’re the unfortunate passenger who will get assigned a nonfunctioning seat, these stats will not matter.

Do what you possibly can to resolve the matter on board, however then observe up on the bottom, have documentation readily available, and make your case firmly however politely … then hope for the most effective.

If you end up in an analogous state of affairs you can’t repair by yourself, ship your drawback to, and I will be blissful that will help you, too.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button