Is American Airways Systematically Denying Compensation Claims?

I’d wish to suppose that I’ve fairly affordable (low) expectations of buyer relations departments at airways, however even by that customary, this appears particularly unhealthy to me.
An unreliable journey to Canada on American Airways
I just lately wrote a few journey that Ford had booked to Canada on American, as he was scheduled to fly American from Miami to Toronto after which American from Montreal to Miami:
- American canceled his outbound flight
- American delayed his return flight, so he misconnected, inflicting an in a single day in Philadelphia
Clearly operational points occur, however what was so irritating is how American dealt with the state of affairs on the return. Often it’s laborious to carry airways accountable, although on this case there’s no less than some recourse.
The Canadian Transportation Company (CTA) has some nice shopper protections, entitling passengers to money compensation within the occasion of delays or cancelations inside a provider’s management. That is considerably just like the EU261 coverage in Europe, and it clearly outlines what passengers are entitled to within the occasion of operational disruptions.
So, whereas Ford would have most well-liked for this journey to only go easily, he’s truly due fairly a bit of money compensation beneath these rules.
Let me additionally emphasize that there are clear pointers about how airways need to deal with complaints concerning authorities mandated air passenger rights. For instance, right here’s American’s web page about air passenger rights involving Canada. The CTA additionally requires airways to both difficulty compensation inside 30 days, or state why compensation isn’t due.
American Airways tries to disregard compensation claims twice
For the reason that outbound and return have been two separate tickets, Ford emailed buyer relations twice, round three weeks aside. In each instances he outlined that he’s searching for the money compensation he’s entitled to beneath Canadian rules, and he even linked to American’s webpage outlining passenger rights. He defined what occurred (that the operational points have been inside American’s management) and what he ought to be entitled to.
He despatched his first criticism on June 26, and acquired the next response on June 27:
Thanks for contacting us.
I’m actually sorry to listen to about your expertise. It’s at all times our aim to run a well timed and dependable operation, and we’re sorry to see we missed the mark in your journey. We’re paying cautious consideration to the suggestions our prospects are offering us and the main points you shared with us have been made out there to our management for use to enhance our service.
As an AAdvantage® member, your corporation means an ideal deal to us, and we’d wish to ask for one more probability to rebuild your confidence. As a tangible type of our apology, we’ve deposited miles into your AAdvantage® account. These miles will likely be seen inside 24 hours.
From all of us at American Airways, we’re glad you selected to fly with us and look ahead to caring for you in your subsequent journey.
He then responded with the next:
Thanks for the response, however this doesn’t tackle my issues. As I defined within the e mail, I’m looking for the money compensation I’m entitled to beneath Canadian regulation, the place my ticket originated. You will discover American’s passenger rights web page for tickets originating in Canada right here.
I recognize your immediate assist with this.
He hasn’t heard from American since then. American does have as much as 30 days to difficulty compensation, so the airline has till round July 26.
Ford submitted his second criticism on July 15, and acquired a response on July 16. Anybody need to guess how that learn? Effectively, it was the identical as the primary e mail, word-for-word.
He then responded with the next:
Thanks for the response, however this doesn’t tackle my issues. As I defined within the e mail, I’m looking for the money compensation I’m entitled to beneath Canadian regulation, given the ticket I used to be booked on. You will discover American’s passenger rights web page for tickets originating in Canada right here.
Permit me to remind you that in keeping with Canadian rules, American has 30 days to present the compensation promised by Canadian regulation. I look ahead to your immediate response.
Look, my expectations of airline buyer relations departments are fairly low in the case of them truly caring about suggestions. However when the airline chooses to blatantly ignore authorities rules, I’d contemplate that to be an issue.
I’m simply confused by American’s technique right here:
- Does American simply not learn emails, and duplicate and paste the identical response for everybody, it doesn’t matter what’s contained within the e mail?
- Does American suppose that the perfect plan of action to keep away from paying compensation is to only provide some AAdvantage bonus miles, and hope that folks will go away? “Boy, I imply, I’m entitled to $1,000 CAD beneath the regulation, however I assume 5,000 AAdvantage miles will do!”
I’ll you should definitely report again on how this goes. If American isn’t dwelling as much as its obligations beneath Canadian regulation, a CTA criticism will likely be filed.
I’m curious, if anybody else has been entitled to authorities mandated compensation from American, did the airline truly comply with the regulation, or attempt to simply ignore it?

Backside line
In some instances, airways are required to pay money compensation beneath the regulation, with clearly outlined guidelines. Ford had a latest journey to Canada the place American was unreliable in each instructions, which entitles him to money compensation.
American appears to be ignoring the regulation, and simply attempting to supply some AAdvantage bonus miles as compensation. As an remoted incident, I’d have assumed that perhaps the agent simply didn’t learn the e-mail accurately. However now twice in a row, American has tried to disregard these claims.
What’s your tackle how American buyer relations is dealing with this?